Sooner or later a candidate you placed leaves in the first few weeks. The client calls, and the only question that matters is what your terms say.
A clear guarantee turns that call into a short admin task. A vague one turns it into an argument about a fee you'd already counted as earned, with a client you'd like to keep.
What is a placement guarantee?
It's a promise that if the hire leaves or is let go within a set period, you'll either find a replacement at no extra fee or refund part of the fee. Clients expect one on contingency work. Retained searches usually offer a replacement rather than money back.
How long should your guarantee be?
For contingency placements in the US, 60 to 90 days is the common range. Some firms offer 30 days for junior roles and six months for senior ones.
A longer guarantee can win you business. But every extra month is a month the fee might come back, so don't offer six months because a competitor does. Offer what your placements can actually stand behind.
Whatever you choose, start the clock on the candidate's start date, not the offer date, and say so in your terms.
Refund or replacement?
A replacement guarantee keeps the money and costs you time. A refund keeps your time and costs you money.
Many firms offer a replacement first, and a refund only if they can't replace within a set window, such as 60 days. That's usually the best of both: the client gets a fair remedy, and you get a chance to keep the fee.
If you do refund, a sliding scale is fairer than all-or-nothing. Here's an example on a $20,000 fee with a 90-day guarantee:
- Leaves in the first 30 days: you refund 75%, so $15,000.
- Days 31 to 60: you refund 50%, so $10,000.
- Days 61 to 90: you refund 25%, so $5,000.
- After day 90: no refund.
The conditions that keep it fair
A guarantee isn't insurance against everything. Most terms make it conditional on a few things:
- The fee was paid within your payment terms. No payment, no guarantee.
- The client told you within a few days of the person leaving.
- The role didn't change materially after the hire.
- The person didn't leave because of a layoff, a restructure or the role moving.
- The client doesn't rehire the same person later. If they do, the original fee is due again.
Know which placements are still covered
The real risk isn't the guarantee itself. It's forgetting which fees are still inside their window when you plan cash or pay commission.
If you pay commission on hire and the fee comes back on day 40, do you claw the commission back too? Your commission plan should say, and your recruiters should know before it happens, not after.
Keep the start date on the placement record and you'll always know which fees are still at risk. It's one more reason to raise the placement invoice from that same record instead of a separate spreadsheet.




